White people paid with their lives for slavery in America with 618,222 dead, being 360,222 Union deaths and 258,000 Confederate deaths. The financial cost of the war was estimated at $5.2 billion US Dollars.
![]() |
| Image by Thure de Thulstrup , via Wikimedia Commons, public domain. |
This country has no guilt to atone for in regard to its black citizens. Certainly, slavery was an enormous evil. But a country that fought a civil war to abolish slavery, has atoned for it on such a scale that to talk about racial quotas in addition, is grotesque However, it is not for injustices committed by the government that the modern racists are demanding reparations, but for racial prejudice — i.e., for the personal views of private citizens.
How can an individual be held responsible for the views of others, whom he has no power to control, who may be his intellectual enemies, whose views may be the opposite of his own? What can make him responsible for them? The answer we hear is: The fact that his skin is of the same color as theirs. If this is not an obliteration of morality, of intellectual integrity, of individual rights, of the freedom of man’s mind (and, incidentally, of the First Amendment), you take it from here; I can’t — it turns my stomach.
It is easy to see how Rand’s argument applies, despite (1) the different forms of the reparations — violating the right to contract via quotas vs. violating property rights via wealth transfers; and (2) the current fashion of pleading “systemic” racism since individual racists are rare and (at least until recently) closeted.
The first paragraph probably would not come as a surprise to anyone who is familiar with Ayn Rand, whom even many opponents would acknowledge as an individualist.
But the second paragraph deserves wide circulation, starting with its acknowledgment of the Civil War as reparation enough, in the only meaning of the term that it can be proper to discuss.
Views: 2
